More than 70% of small businesses don't plan to invite holiday shoppers to an email list
Three in four shoppers say they're likely to try a new small business, and collecting contact details at checkout makes a January follow-up possible.

Constant Contact said Nov. 3 that 75.2% of consumers in its annual holiday survey are likely to shop this season at a small business they have never bought from before. But 70.8% of the small businesses it surveyed don't plan to invite holiday shoppers to join an email list or loyalty program.
The findings come from the company's annual Small Business Now Holiday Report. Only 39% of the businesses plan to send follow-up emails with updates and offers in the new year. And 22.1% aren't planning any specific follow-up to bring holiday shoppers back.
Constant Contact sells email marketing software. It surveyed 1,834 small-business owners and marketers and 2,664 consumers 18 and older in the United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, Australia and New Zealand. The company did not say when the survey ran, and its headline figures combine all five countries.
U.S. owners look somewhat better prepared. In the U.S., 45.5% plan to send follow-up emails after the holidays, more than in any other region. Just 17.5% of U.S. businesses have no specific follow-up plan, compared with 24.0% in the United Kingdom and 25.6% in Canada.
"Three in four shoppers are looking to try a new small business this season, and every one of those first visits is a chance to earn a regular customer," Frank J. Vella, Constant Contact's CEO, said in a statement announcing the report. "The businesses who come out ahead will be the ones with a plan to bring those customers back in February and again in June."
Discounts lead the holiday plan
Discounts are owners' top sales tactic, cited by 38.1%, the report found. Sales and discounts are also the main reason 52.6% of shoppers pick one place to shop over another. Inflation is the top obstacle for 31.5% of consumers and 30.1% of businesses.
More than half of the businesses, 53.4%, said over a quarter of their holiday customers are repeat buyers. Almost 34% plan to introduce new products in January and February.
What a regular customer is worth
Separate data from Square points to the value of customers who keep coming back. Square, which also sells email, text and loyalty tools, published its 2026 Local Economy Report on March 18. It defines a regular as a customer who visits a business at least four times a year.
Square found that regulars generate six times more annual revenue than one-time visitors. Among its sellers using its email, text or loyalty products, 90% kept regular customers in 2025. Among sellers that didn't use them, 38% did.
That comparison shows a link. It does not prove the tools caused the difference, since businesses that sign up for marketing tools may differ in other ways. These Square figures come only from its own sellers' data, covering transactions from January 2019 through December 2025.
Turning a first visit into a second
The first job is getting a way to reach each new customer before they leave. That can be a sign-up at the register, a loyalty card or a box on the online order form. A service business can ask at the end of the job. Ask plainly, and say what the customer gets in return, such as a perk on the next visit.
U.S. owners already lean this way. The report found 36.2% of them plan to offer coupons or discounts on a future purchase after the holidays, more than in any other region. A discount that only works in January or February gives a holiday shopper a reason to come back after the rush.
Mark first-time holiday customers so they get a different message from longtime regulars. A short thank-you within a week, an offer in January and a note about new products in February make a simple plan. Writing those messages now, before the rush, keeps them from slipping.
Owners can keep a note on what each new customer bought, or what job they did at the customer's house. That gives the follow-up something specific to say. Vella made the same point in the announcement. "AI can draft the email in seconds, but it's the florist who knows a customer orders peonies every spring who makes that message land," he said.
Small Business Saturday falls on Nov. 28 this year. That leaves owners just over three weeks to have a sign-up ready at the counter and on the order form.



