Federal judge lets $500-per-email suit over Ulta's 'free gifts' subject lines proceed
The law reaches any business emailing customers it knows live in Indiana, so holiday 'free gift' and 'last day' lines need a check.

A federal judge ruled Sept. 15 that Indiana shoppers can pursue a proposed class action against Ulta over subject lines such as "SO MANY FREE GIFTS INSIDE." The Indiana law behind the suit sets damages at $500 per email.
U.S. District Judge Justin R. Olson let the claim go forward even though the bodies of the emails spelled out minimum purchases and brand exclusions.
The order resolves a motion to dismiss. It makes no finding that Ulta broke the law.
Jones Day warned email marketers about the ruling in an October alert, and Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz followed in a Nov. 2 blog post.
What the Ulta order says
The suit falls under the Indiana Deceptive Commercial Electronic Mail Act, a 2003 law. It bars marketing emails with "false or misleading information in the subject line."
The ban covers emails to people the sender knows, or has reason to know, live in Indiana. Plaintiffs don't have to prove they were harmed.
The plaintiffs say Ulta emailed them from about November 2023 to August 2025 with subject lines promising "free" gifts and percentage discounts. One read "Don't miss 10% off your purchase," while fine print excluded some brands. The complaint quotes the subject lines of 166 free-gift emails and 10 discount emails.
The judge threw out the claim that the subject lines were false. The law looks at "the entire message," he wrote, and the plaintiffs never claimed Ulta failed to offer the gifts or discounts.
But he kept the claim that the lines were misleading. The plaintiffs alleged that they would not have opened the emails had the subject lines mentioned the fine print.
"Whether any reasonable jury could find that Ulta's emails are misleading is a question for another day," Olson wrote.
He also rejected Ulta's argument that the federal CAN-SPAM Act overrides that claim. CAN-SPAM itself does not let private citizens sue, though internet service providers can, the order notes.
Why owners outside Indiana should pay attention
The Indiana statute lets recipients sue any "person who initiates or assists the transmission" of a marketing email that breaks it.
Knowing where a customer lives can bring a sender within the law's reach. The Ulta plaintiffs had Ulta customer accounts with Indiana billing and shipping addresses. The judge found the complaint plausibly alleged that Ulta knew they lived there.
A small online shop that stores shipping addresses holds the same kind of record. The judge also noted that not knowing where recipients live is a defense.
Indiana is a new front. After Washington's Supreme Court read that state's similar law broadly in 2025, nearly 200 class actions followed, according to Jones Day.
Washington lawmakers then changed the law, effective June 11. Senders must now know a line is misleading, and damages fell to $100 per email. Indiana's law has neither limit, the firm said.
"Indiana could become an increasingly attractive forum for plaintiffs pursuing email subject-line class actions," Caren Decter and Peter Devlin of Frankfurt Kurnit wrote.
Subject lines with deadlines draw suits too. Costco, which denied wrongdoing, agreed to pay $14 million to settle a Washington case over limited-time offers, Fox Business reported in July. One cited example read "Today is the last day to access Member-Only Savings."
On Aug. 18, two shoppers sued Ulta in Indiana state court over deadline emails, according to Claim Depot, which tracks class actions.
According to its summary of the complaint, one email billed itself as the last day of a 50%-off sale. Ulta allegedly announced a "BONUS DAY" extending it the next morning. Another "last day" sale allegedly ran again a week later.
Checking holiday subject lines before they go out
Black Friday falls on Nov. 27 this year and Cyber Monday on Nov. 30.
This article is not legal advice, and owners with Indiana customers should ask a lawyer about their own lists. But the cases point to a few simple checks.
Read each subject line on its own, with nothing else on the screen. Jones Day advised making sure "the subject line can stand alone as neither false nor misleading."
Devlin gave similar advice in June. He wrote that companies should review their claims about "urgency, availability, pricing, and 'free' offers." The subject line should reflect "the terms and length of the promotion," he added.
If a free gift needs a minimum order, say so up front, as in "Free gift with orders over $50." If a discount skips some brands or services, add "on select items."
Treat "last day" and "ends tonight" as promises. If a sale might run long, don't call it final.
Don't extend or rerun a sale you said was over. If you plan a follow-up deal, make it a different offer with its own terms.
Have someone who did not write the campaign check every holiday subject line against the actual offer terms. Keep a copy of each email and its offer rules.
In the Ulta case, one open question may go to the Indiana Supreme Court. It is whether a misleading subject line must concern a "material fact." Olson wrote that he is inclined to send it there if it ends up deciding the case.



